1851

<p>When the <a href="https://www.nlrb.gov/news-outreach/news-story/board-issues-decision-browning-ferris-industries?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=nlrb-for-franchising-explained-2884" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">National Labor Relations Board</a> ruled in August 2015 that companies using workers hired by an outside business are jointly responsible for workplace violations, those embedded in the world of franchising were left with a sense of uncertainty and unease.</p><div>The Browning-Ferris Industries case may ultimately redefine what constitutes an employer-employee relationship in the franchising context. <a href="http://www.gpmlaw.com/People/Carl-Zwisler?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=nlrb-for-franchising-explained-2884" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">Carl Zwisler</a>, principal at Gary Plant Mooty, said the decision is interesting because the NLRB overturned the joint employer standard that has been in place since the 1980s to include all types of business relationships.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>&#8220;I can understand the rationale, but I don&#8217;t understand is why they adopted the new joint employer standard,&#8221; he said. &#8220;It was not needed to decide the case.&#8221;</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>Zwisler has long been affiliated with franchising. He has served the IFA in various capacities since 1975, and as a lawyer, he advises and represents companies expanding through franchising. He said that although the ruling hasn&#8217;t been applied to franchising yet, it could have a significant effect on the franchising business model.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>&#8220;Under the new joint employer standard, if a franchisor or other putative joint employer has the right, directly or indirectly, to exercise control over employment decisions, if it&#8217;s applied to franchising would be very frightening,&#8221; Zwisler said.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>Although virtually no franchise agreement grants a franchisor the right to exercise control over the terms of employment of a franchisee&#8217;s employees, almost every franchise agreement grants the franchisor the right to establish and modify standards of operation of franchised outlets. Those broad reservations of power could be seized by the NLRB to characterize a franchisor as a joint employer with a franchisee in regard to operating standards that affect or may affect how a franchisee&#8217;s employees perform their jobs.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>&#8220;If a union decides they want to pursue unfair labor practices charges against a franchisee and franchisor as joint employers, or if a union seeks an election to represent employees that they claim are employed by both the franchisee and its franchisor, most franchisees and franchisors will not be prepared to handle the situation,&#8221; Zwisler said.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>Concerned with how the ruling may be applied to franchises, many brands are taking a step back from providing valuable support to franchisees. Implementing sound practices is essential for any business owner, but some franchisors are now stepping away from providing best-practices information, such as training manuals and programs and sample employee handbooks.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>&#8220;We have been recommending franchisors scrutinize their manuals and procedures, handbooks and training programs to closely exam if they are providing advice or direction that could tie them to a joint-employment relationship,&#8221; Zwisler said.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>Franchisors are also increasingly concerned about vicarious liability claims under which they must defend accusations of negligence, sexual harassment, and wages and hour law violations by their franchisees.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>Ironically, in one of the most significant vicarious liability cases decided during the last two years, Domino&#8217;s was held not to be liable for the sexual harassment of a franchisee&#8217;s assistant manager. This is substantial because Domino&#8217;s did not provide sexual harassment training to its franchisees. Unfortunately, franchisors are being punished in the courts for providing services to franchisees that public policy should embrace. It seems that no good deed goes unpunished in this area of the law.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>Ultimately, what it really boils down to is franchisors fear the unknown.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>Many worry the NLRB ruling has changed franchising as we know it. Concern about the joint employer standard has led to all sorts of about what the consequences of being a joint employer would mean to a franchising chain.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>So far, the only joint employer case we are only aware of is the NLRB&#8217;s complaint against McDonald&#8217;s. NLRB General Counsel Richard Griffin has refused to identify the facts which he believes are the basis for his joint employer allegation. Franchise lawyers have been searching for his reasoning so they can intelligently advise clients about whether or how to change their agreements or contact to avoid claims.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>&#8220;Until we know what franchise agreement or other language, policies and procedures are likely to lead to claims, we are unable to offer specific advice to our clients,&#8221; Zwisler said.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>According to Zwisler, despite the forecasters of doom, it is entirely possible that once the factual foundations of a successful joint employer clam are known, franchisors and unsuccessful defendants could amend its agreement or policies and avoid liability going forward.</div><div>&nbsp;</div><div>&#8220;Unfortunately, as the speculation continues, some prospective franchisees, lenders and investors are looking skeptically at the franchise model,&#8221; he said. &#8220;Although vigilance and re-examination of policies and procedures is beneficial, fear-mongering is helping no one in the franchising community.&#8221;</div>

1851 Franchise

A longtime franchise expert shares his thoughts on what the Browning-Ferris Industries case means.

This brand page has been paid for by 1851. Content within this page that is paid will showcase a Sponsored icon. This means the brand has engaged 1851 FRANCHISE to write the content. Content without the Sponsored Icon is aggregated media placements the brand earned. Questions can be sent to editorial@1851franchise.com

NLRB for Franchising Explained 

nlrb-for-franchising-explained

Onigilly Japanese Kitchen

Unlocking the Potential: How Much Can You Earn as an Onigilly Franchisee?

unlocking-the-potential-how-much-can-you-earn-as-an-onigilly-franchisee

Filta Environmental Kitchen Solutions

DeWitts Ignite New Chapter for Filta Environmental Kitchen Solutions in Reno 

Grease, Grit, and Growth: DeWitts Ignite New Chapter for Filta Environmental Kitchen Solutions in Reno, Nevada

grease-grit-and-growth-dewitts-ignite-new-chapter-for-filta-environmental-kitchen-solutions-in-reno-nevada

Layne's Chicken Fingers

Layne's Chicken Fingers-50 Unit-Wendy's-Franchisee-June-2025

Why This 50 Unit Wendy’s Franchisee Is Betting on Layne’s for His Next Big Move

wendys-franchisee-expands-with-laynes-chicken-fingers-texas

CapitalSpring

CapitalSpring’s Jim Balis Talks Growth, ROI and the Future of Fast Casual on “Rock My Restaurant”

capitalsprings-jim-balis-talks-growth-roi-and-the-future-of-fast-casual-on-rock-my-restaurant

Children's Lighthouse

Children’s Lighthouse Ramps Up Growth in First Half of 2025 With Strategic Expansions, Franchise Signings, and New Headquarters

childrens-lighthouse-ramps-up-growth-in-first-half-of-2025-with-strategic-expansions-franchise-signings-and-new-headquarters

Buying a Franchise Masterclass

 Franchise Opportunities

Get Support Buying a Franchise

How to Buy a Franchise White Paper

How to Buy a Franchise

How to Sell Franchises

How to Grow a Franchise

Find a Franchise Supplier

1851 Franchise Opportunities

Franchisor News

Franchisor Power Rankings

FranCamp Mastermind Summit

Franchise Development Website Builder

Franchise Resources

What ALEC-Laffer's Report Means for Franchising

Website Awards

Power Rankings

About 1851

Advertise on 1851

Contact 1851 Editorial

Terms of Use

1851 Login

GROWTH CLUB LOGIN

facebook

instagram

twitter

linkedin

youtube

What June’s Jobs Report Means for the Franchise Industry

what-junes-jobs-report-means-for-the-franchise-industry

Drone Delivery Takes Flight in QSR: The Future of Franchise Operations?

drone-delivery-takes-flight-in-qsr-the-future-of-franchise-operations

Chick-fil-A Tops Customer Satisfaction Rankings for 11th Year as Challenger Brands Gain Ground

chick-fil-a-tops-customer-satisfaction-rankings-for-11th-year-as-challenger-brands-gain-ground

Technomic Releases Annual Ranking of the Top 15 Fast-Food Chains in the U.S.

technomic-releases-annual-ranking-of-the-top-15-fast-food-chains-in-the-us

Rising Jobless Claims Could Signal Challenges — and Opportunities — for Franchising

rising-jobless-claims-affect-franchising

The Ultimate Guide to Selling Franchises: How To Create a Strong Incentive

how-to-build-strong-incentives-to-attract-prospective-franchisees

Top 25 Franchise Marketing Leaders: Carol DeNembo — Chief Marketing Officer, Mountain Mike’s Pizza

top-25-franchise-marketing-leaders-carol-denembo-chief-marketing-officer-mountain-mikes-pizza

Top 25 Franchise Marketing Leaders: Kelsey McManemin — Vice President of Marketing, HTeaO

top-25-franchise-marketing-leaders-kelsey-mcmanemin-vice-president-of-marketing-hteao

Missy Maio - Gong Cha - Top Franchise Marketing Leaders - 1851 Franchise

Top 25 Franchise Marketing Leaders: Missy Maio — Vice President of Marketing and Global Partnerships, Gong Cha

franchise-marketing-leader-missy-maio-gong-cha

How Vishal Juneja Turned a Family Tradition Into a Paris Baguette Franchise

How Vishal Juneja Turned a Family Tradition Into a Paris Baguette Franchise Built on Heart and Community

paris-baguette-franchise-rockaway-new-jersey-vishal-junjea

petbar Franchise Costs, Fees, Profit and Data for 2025

petbar-franchise-deep-dive

Design with outline of three houses and people working on laptops within them

Top 10 Low-Cost Home-Based or Mobile Franchises for 2025

low-cost-home-based-mobile-franchises

Franchisee spotlight graphic with photo of Juan & Whitney Fernandez & family, BIGGBY COFFEE logo

From Chiropractic to Coffee: These BIGGBY® COFFEE Franchisees Are Brewing Something New in Troy, Ohio 

biggby-coffee-franchise-coming-to-troy-ohio

NLRB for Franchising Explained

MORE STORIES LIKE THIS