1851

When a franchise contract prohibits one franchisee from hiring employees of another franchisee without their consent, it is called a “no-poach agreement.” This rule is designed to ensure one franchisee doesn’t save the time, expense and effort of training by hiring the employees of other franchisees who have already made the required investment outlined in the agreement. Over the past few years, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has gone back and forth over the legality of no-poach agreements. Now, Biden has announced his plans to ban the provision for franchise brands.In October 2016, the DOJ issued guidance to human resource professionals stating that no-poach agreements between employers were per se illegal and subject to criminal prosecution under Section 1 of the <a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/sherman_antitrust_act?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=what-is-a-franchise-no-poach-agreement-and-why-is-biden-looking-to-ban-them-2717556" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">Sherman Antitrust Act</a>, which prohibits agreements that unreasonably restrain trade. If a provision is considered a per se restraint — or a horizontal restraint — it is considered harmful to competition, and a plaintiff is not required to prove that the challenged agreement in fact hinders competition in their market.This 2016 directive resulted in employees of franchisees filing numerous civil damage suits, including class actions, against both franchisors and franchisees. So far, many of those cases are still pending, and the initial rulings for those that have gone through have been varied.In 2019, under the Trump administration, the DOJ backpedaled on the 2016 directive and declared that no-poach agreements between franchisors and franchisees should be judged by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_reason?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=what-is-a-franchise-no-poach-agreement-and-why-is-biden-looking-to-ban-them-2717556" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">the rule of reason</a>, because they are “vertical restraints” that could theoretically benefit overall industry competition.&nbsp;For example, the practice of franchisees being able to avoid training fees and costs by poaching employees of fellow franchisees could damage a franchise brand’s systemwide growth, thus hindering overall advancement of the industry. The rule of reason argument also suggests employees of franchisees can benefit from no-poach agreements because those agreements give the franchisees the incentive to invest in the training and development of their employees, who are free to use those skills at a competing brand.This 2019 declaration also noted that no-poach agreements between a franchisor and franchisees that both operate stores in competition with each other, as well as between competing franchisees, should still be judged under the per se rule.Now, Biden has promised to ban all no-poach agreements, which means the DOJ will likely begin criminal prosecutions of franchise no-poach agreements once again. If the franchise industry as a whole hopes to maintain the legal practice of no-poach agreements, they will need to prove their positive effect on competition as well as their ability to create upward mobility for employees and increased compensation.

What is a Franchise “No Poach Agreement,” and Why is Biden Looking to Ban Them?

1851 Franchise

The controversial provision — which ensures franchisees cannot non-consensually hire employees from other franchisees — is under fire once again.

what-is-a-franchise-no-poach-agreement-and-why-is-biden-looking-to-ban-them

Lawn Doctor

Design with photo of John Perry and Lawn Doctor logo

How a 20-Year Industry Veteran Tripled His Sales With a Lawn Doctor Franchise

lawn-doctor-franchise-success-story-john-perry

Fitness Premier

The Secret to Fitness Franchise Success? It's Not Just the Workouts

fitness-premier-franchise-marketing-support

Fresh Coat

Photo of Fresh Coat vehicle with ladders on top

The Rise of Home Improvement Franchises: Why Now Is the Time to Invest

why-invest-home-improvement-franchise-fresh-coat

HomeTeam Inspection Service

Photo of HomeTeam inspector in red polo and khaki pants, walking by branded vehicle

Real Estate Today: Behind the Drywall: The Truth About Home Inspections

purpose-of-home-inspection

Dog Training Elite

Dog Training Elite Franchise - DTE - National Service Dog Month - 1851 Franchise

Celebrating Service Dogs: Why Proper Training Changes Lives — And How Dog Training Elite Is Leading the Way

dog-training-elite-national-service-dog-month

Buying a Franchise Masterclass

 Franchise Opportunities

Get Support Buying a Franchise

How to Buy a Franchise White Paper

How to Buy a Franchise

How to Sell Franchises

How to Grow a Franchise

Find a Franchise Supplier

1851 Franchise Opportunities

Franchisor News

Franchisor Power Rankings

FranCamp Mastermind Summit

Franchise Development Website Builder

Franchise Resources

What ALEC-Laffer's Report Means for Franchising

Website Awards

Power Rankings

About 1851

Advertise on 1851

Contact 1851 Editorial

Terms of Use

1851 Login

GROWTH CLUB LOGIN

facebook

instagram

twitter

linkedin

youtube

Design with American and Federal Reserve flags against light blue background

Federal Reserve Expected To Cut Rates by Quarter Point, a Move That Could Boost Franchise Growth

fed-rate-cut-boosts-franchise-growth

Potbelly to be Acquired by RaceTrac in $566 Million Deal 

racetrac-acquires-potbelly-in-566-million-deal

Health Care Hiring Slowdown Highlights In-Home Care Franchise Opportunities - 1851 Franchise Agg

Health Care Hiring Slowdown Highlights In-Home Care Franchise Opportunities 

health-care-hiring-slowdown-in-home-care-franchise-opportunities

Caribou Coffee Names Scott Kennedy CEO, Eyes Continued Growth

caribou-coffee-names-scott-kennedy-ceo-eyes-continued-growth

McDonald’s Launches New Extra Value Meals as Consumer Demand for Value Continues to Climb

mcdonalds-launches-extra-value-meals

Technomic Releases Annual Ranking of the Top 15 Fast-Food Chains in the U.S.

technomic-releases-annual-ranking-of-the-top-15-fast-food-chains-in-the-us

Friendly’s Parent Company Acquired by Multi-Unit Franchisee as More Owners Take the Lead in Brand Acquisitions 

friendlys-parent-company-acquired-by-multi-unit-franchisee-as-more-owners-take-the-lead-in-brand-acquisitions

Hely and Hiral Patel Bring Their Longtime Dream to Life With The Brass Tap

brass-tap-franchise-pasadena-maryland-hely-hiral-patel

1851 Keyword - The Secret To Succeeding With a Part-Time Franchise Is Picking the Right Model

The Secret To Succeeding With a Part-Time Franchise Is Picking the Right Model

part-time-franchises-picking-the-right-model

Franchisee spotlight graphic with photo of Ricki Oberoi and Layne's Chicken Fingers logo

Multi-Unit Wendy’s Operator Signs 12-Unit Deal With Layne’s Chicken Fingers

ricki-oberoi-laynes-chicken-fingers-growth

DevHub - Meet the Supplier - 1851 Franchise

DevHub: Scalable Digital Marketing for Franchises and Multi-Location Brands

devhub-meet-the-supplier

1851 Franchise Deep Dive graphic with Sparkle Squad logo

Sparkle Squad Franchise Costs, Fees, Profit and Data for 2025

franchise-deep-dive-sparkle-squad-franchise-costs-fees-profit-and-data

Design with school-aged child standing on pencil with text "Education Franchises" and "<$500K"

Top Education Franchises Under $500K To Explore in 2025

top-education-franchises-under-500k

What is a Franchise “No Poach Agreement,” and Why is Biden Looking to Ban Them?

MORE STORIES LIKE THIS