McDonald's AI Pricing Tool Puts Franchisee Price Control Under the Microscope

McDonald's is leaning more heavily on an AI pricing engine to recommend menu prices across its nearly 14,000 U.S. restaurants. Several franchisees told Reuters the guidance has become difficult to ignore.

The system uses machine learning to sift millions of daily transactions and recommend a price for every item at every location. Inputs include estimates of what customers in a given area are willing to pay and posted menu prices from nearby competitors such as Wendy's and Burger King. McDonald's has used some version of the tool since at least 2019 and sends guidance at least three times a year, according to company documents Reuters reviewed.

The question is how optional that guidance really is. Five store owners told Reuters the company pressured them to adopt the recommendations. A June document also showed that McDonald's tracks deviations in detail. Since January, the brand's business standards have required franchisees to engage constructively with its approved pricing consultant and tools.

CEO Chris Kempczinski told investors in August that pricing non-compliance can come up in franchisee business reviews. Reuters noted that the company also controls decisions such as whether an operator can renew or open new stores.

McDonald's earns most of its money from a percentage of franchisee sales. That means lower prices can benefit the company if they bring more customers through the door, even if they squeeze a restaurant's margins. Franchisees are also dealing with higher operating costs. The National Restaurant Association estimates those costs are up 36% since 2019.

Reuters reported that the pricing engine has recently recommended more conservative prices, including some cuts. Kempczinski said roughly one-third of owners did not follow the chain's guidance to keep some menu items under $3.

McDonald's disputes that characterization. In an Oct. 1 statement on its corporate site, the company said AI does not set or change menu prices and that it does not use dynamic pricing. It added that franchisees independently decide what to charge and are not required to accept a recommendation, and it described the portal to Reuters as “a tool, not a mandate.”

The portal's terms warn that owners may be competitors and must follow antitrust law. William Kovacic, a former Federal Trade Commission commissioner, told Reuters the language reflects concerns about the way the system could be used.

Other legal experts told Reuters the risk of an antitrust violation is low. Courts have generally given franchisors broad authority over franchisee pricing. McDonald's also said it takes antitrust compliance seriously.

For franchisors, the bigger question is whether their policies match how their technology is actually used. If a brand calls pricing recommendations voluntary, its standards and business reviews should reflect that. Prospective franchisees should ask how pricing guidance is delivered and whether following it can affect renewal or expansion approvals. Calls to current owners listed in Item 20 of the franchise disclosure document are the most direct way to learn how much latitude franchisees really have.

Read the full article here.

Want to learn more about how 1851 helps franchisees find the right franchise opportunity? Visit www.1851growthclub.com and start your journey.