1851

Franchisors could once again be sued for the employment practices and policies of their franchisees as the result of <a href="https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/operations/joint-employer-threat-franchising-back?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=recent-court-ruling-brings-joint-employer-threat-back-to-franchising-2713838" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">a federal judge’s decision this week to overturn the Trump Administration’s redefinition of “joint employer,”</a> a legal standard the franchise community has struggled with for years.In February, <a href="https://1851franchise.com/nlrb-finalizes-ruling-to-reduce-joint-employer-liability-for-franchisors-2712391#stories">the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) published a final rule updating its joint-employer regulations</a>. According to the new ruling, franchisees could be considered a joint employer of an operator's employees <a href="https://www.qsrmagazine.com/legal/nlrb-businesses-must-have-substantial-control-be-joint-employer?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=recent-court-ruling-brings-joint-employer-threat-back-to-franchising-2713838" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">only if the franchise maintained “substantial control” over the workers' essential terms of employment</a>. The NLRB defined these essential terms exclusively as “wages, benefits, hours of work, hiring, discharge, discipline, supervision and direction.”&nbsp;This assured franchisors that they wouldn’t be repeatedly dragged into court by employees looking to sue a big corporation for alleged violations of federal labor regulations. Franchisees also expressed relief that they could continue to oversee the responsibility of recruiting and maintaining a staff, instead of having to involve a franchisor that might have no familiarity with the local labor market.The ruling came after <a href="https://1851franchise.com/what-the-nlrb-s-recent-rulings-really-mean-for-the-franchise-business-model-3408">years of concern over non-compliance following the board's decision</a> to <a href="https://www.nlrb.gov/news-outreach/news-story/board-issues-decision-browning-ferris-industries?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=recent-court-ruling-brings-joint-employer-threat-back-to-franchising-2713838" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">broaden the interpretation of joint-employer status</a> in 2015. After the NLRB expanded the joint employer definition, <a href="https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/dol-narrows-joint-employer-definition-in-final-rule/570303/?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=recent-court-ruling-brings-joint-employer-threat-back-to-franchising-2713838" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">joint employer lawsuits increased 93%</a> and cost individual franchise businesses an average of $42,000, <a href="https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/operations/research-puts-price-joint-employer-confusion-333b-annually?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=recent-court-ruling-brings-joint-employer-threat-back-to-franchising-2713838" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">according to the International Franchise Association</a>. In fact, many foodservice franchisors considered cutting back on or halting franchising entirely to avoid this increased liability.In December of 2019, the NLRB began showing signs of moving toward reducing franchisors' responsibility over their operators' infractions. McDonald’s — the largest fast food chain in the world — <a href="https://1851franchise.com/national-labor-relations-board-mcdonalds-is-not-a-joint-employer-2711854#stories">won an appeals case in which the NLRB ruled the brand was not considered a joint employer</a> and therefore should not be subjected to penalties for labor violations alongside its franchisees.Overall, the updated regulatory landscape brought relief to established franchisors and independent businesses that were looking to expand through franchising. Still, many worried these updates could be <a href="https://1851franchise.com/no-more-burger-brawls-mcdonalds-employees-sue-for-company-failure-to-mediate-workplace-violence-2711690#most-recent">discouraging to labor groups that have tried to hold corporate restaurants accountable</a> for the bad actions of their operators.&nbsp;Now, the U.S. District Court Judge Gregory Woods has overturned the redefinition, saying Labor failed to explain adequately why its interpretation of “joint employer” had changed. The ruling also asserted that the new standard is not consistent with the <a href="https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/flsa?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=recent-court-ruling-brings-joint-employer-threat-back-to-franchising-2713838" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">Fair Labor Standards Act</a>, the nearly 100-year-old piece of legislation that set up such protections for workers as a federal minimum wage, a limitation on weekly hours and the National Labor Relations Board.The plaintiffs argued that the new definition denied workers a chance to push back on unfair operational policies that were handed down to franchisees by their franchisors, which many argue have an impact on staff duties and responsibilities.&nbsp;According to <a href="https://1851franchise.com/top-franchise-lawyers-jonathan-barber-esq-of-franchiselaw-2713416">Jonathan Barber, Esq., Managing Attorney</a> at <a href="https://franchise.law/?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=recent-court-ruling-brings-joint-employer-threat-back-to-franchising-2713838" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">Franchise.Law</a>, this redefinition, while inconvenient, won’t really change much for most franchisors. “It was nice for the NLRB to clarify its definition of a joint employer, however, the real test is whether a franchisor has too much involvement in its franchisees' human resource practices,” he said. “If a franchisor prescribes a minimum number of employees and basic qualifications for them, they shouldn't be afraid of being labeled a joint employer. However, if a franchisor itself interviews each of its franchisees' prospective employees, conducts background checks, trains the employees and otherwise participates in the overall management of those employees, they'll most likely be found to be a joint employer. The best practice is for franchisors to give minimum staffing guidelines and to let their franchisees handle all of their employment needs.”While the ruling may just put franchisors back to where they started, it will likely still prove frustrating to the franchise community, which has seen a more-favorable joint employer standard be adopted and then repealed multiple times. The International Franchise Association (IFA) and other groups have even pushed to stop this constant back and forth by having Congress set a definition as law, which would prevent a rewrite of the definition every time control of the White House should shift from one political party to another.&nbsp;&nbsp;Luckily, the recent ruling doesn’t necessarily spell disaster for franchisors, who are already struggling amid the pandemic. “This court decision basically challenges whether the NLRB properly implemented its new definition of a joint employer,” said Barber. “It doesn't set a new standard, holding that all franchisors are joint employers simply by virtue of their franchise relationship. That would be catastrophic.”

Recent Court Ruling Brings ‘Joint Employer’ Threat Back to Franchising

1851 Franchise

After a brief victory earlier this year, the federal court has overturned the definition favored by franchisors and franchisees.

recent-court-ruling-brings-joint-employer-threat-back-to-franchising

The Growth Coach

Building a Business and a Life With The Growth Coach

building-a-business-and-a-life-with-the-growth-coach

Dillas Quesadillas

The Top 7 Reasons To Buy a Dillas Primo Quesadillas Franchise

the-top-7-reasons-to-buy-a-dillas-primo-quesadillas-franchise

KLA Schools

A Day in the Life of KLA Schools Franchisee Sital Patel

a-day-in-the-life-of-a-kla-schools-franchisee

Keke's Breakfast Cafe

image of keke's breakfast cafe franchise Jon Ahrendt and John Ehrhard

Jon Ahrendt and John Ehrhard To Share Insights on Franchise Growth and Work-Life Balance With Keke’s Breakfast Cafe in Upcoming Webinar

kekes-breakfast-cafe-franchise-ahrendt-ehrhard-webinar

Minuteman Press International

Minuteman Press franchise owners Karen Fraielli and Valerie Chanoux with their 25-year Award.

Minuteman Press Franchisees Celebrate 25+ Years in Warwick, RI

minuteman-press-franchisees-celebrate-25-years-in-warwick-ri

Buying a Franchise Masterclass

 Franchise Opportunities

Get Support Buying a Franchise

How to Buy a Franchise White Paper

How to Buy a Franchise

How to Sell Franchises

How to Grow a Franchise

Find a Franchise Supplier

1851 Franchise Opportunities

Franchisor News

Franchisor Power Rankings

FranCamp Mastermind Summit

Franchise Development Website Builder

Franchise Resources

What ALEC-Laffer's Report Means for Franchising

Website Awards

Power Rankings

About 1851

Advertise on 1851

Contact 1851 Editorial

Terms of Use

1851 Login

GROWTH CLUB LOGIN

facebook

instagram

twitter

linkedin

youtube

How a Steady Economy Could Help Franchisors Plan Their Next Move

how-a-steady-economy-could-help-franchisors-plan-their-next-move

Bed Bath & Beyond - Franchise Expansion - Retail Strategy - 1851 Franchise

Bed Bath & Beyond Launches Franchise Model as Part of Comeback Strategy

bed-bath-beyond-franchise-expansion-retail-strategy

Senior Entrepreneurship - Franchising - 1851 Franchise

Senior Entrepreneurship Is Rising — And Franchising Is a Key Outlet

senior-entrepreneurship-franchising-silver-startups

U.S. Government Shutdown - Impact on Franchises - 1851 Franchise

Government Shutdown Stalls SBA Loans: How the Shutdown Could Impact Franchises

government-shutdown-impacts-sba-loans-tourism-franchises

Subway Franchisees Resist Expensive Remodel Directives

subway-franchisees-resist-expensive-remodel-directives

NJCAR v. Ford - New Jersey Supreme Court Limits Standing Under Franchise Practices Act

New Jersey Supreme Court Limits Standing Under Franchise Practices Act

new-jersey-franchise-practices-act-njcar-v-ford

Power Eats: Smoothie King Rolls Out Food Nationwide To Fuel Franchise Growth

smoothie-king-food-menu-power-eats

Friendly’s Parent Company Acquired by Multi-Unit Franchisee as More Owners Take the Lead in Brand Acquisitions 

friendlys-parent-company-acquired-by-multi-unit-franchisee-as-more-owners-take-the-lead-in-brand-acquisitions

Top Early Childhood Education and Child Care Franchises for 2025 - 1851 Franchise

Top Early Childhood Education and Child Care Franchises for 2025

early-childhood-education-child-care-franchises

Top Education Franchises To Consider for 2025 - 1851 Franchise

Top Education Franchises To Consider Investing In for 2025

top-education-franchises-investment-opportunities

image of franchise deep dive from 1851 franchise on doody calls franchise authority brands

DoodyCalls Franchise Costs, Fees, Profit and Data for 2025

doodycalls-franchise-deep-dive

1851 Franchisee Spotlight graphic with photo of Barb Volk and KidStrong logo

Why This Orangetheory Fitness Franchise Owner Is Developing KidStrong Franchises

kidstrong-franchise-owner-barb-volk-2025

Recent Court Ruling Brings ‘Joint Employer’ Threat Back to Franchising

MORE STORIES LIKE THIS