1851

1851: Tell us about your background and your firm.

<a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/carl-zwisler-78609711/?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=franchise-legal-players-carl-zwisler-principal-at-gray-plant-mooty-2709549" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" style="text-decoration-line:none" target="_blank">Carl Zwisler</a>, Principal at <a href="https://www.gpmlaw.com/?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=franchise-legal-players-carl-zwisler-principal-at-gray-plant-mooty-2709549" target="_blank" rel="nofollow" style="text-decoration-line:none" target="_blank">Gray Plant Mooty</a>: I began my career in franchising on the IFA staff, where I was responsible for IFA&rsquo;s legal and governmental affairs programs. Since leaving IFA, I have been engaged in the private practice of franchise law in Washington, D.C., principally representing franchisors and master franchisees, with an emphasis on outbound and inbound international franchising. &nbsp;For the last 10 years, I have worked in the Washington office of Gray Plant Mooty, a 153-year-old general business firm which hosts an elite team of 30+ full-time franchise lawyers and six franchise paralegals.

1851: What are some must-ask questions when franchisors and franchisees are vetting potential franchise attorneys? 

Zwisler: &lsquo;What experience do you have representing franchisors and franchisees? Who are your clients? What distinguishes you and your franchise group from other franchise lawyers? What experience do lawyers from other practice areas in your firm, such as IP, corporate, employment and tax law have with franchising issues? Why is your firm more efficient than others at providing franchising legal services? How are you and your firm recognized by third parties for their franchising practices?&rsquo;

1851: In broad terms, do you have a particular case that stands out to you as an industry learning experience? 

Zwisler: The anti-poaching investigations and state attorneys generals&rsquo; demands that franchisors eliminate anti-poaching language from their franchise agreements throughout the U.S. provide a real learning experience for franchisors. Anti-poaching language was adopted by many franchisors to protect the investment that their franchisees make in training managers and key employees, and to encourage cooperation among franchisees, while minimizing inter-brand bickering. Until the end of 2017, only one or two cases involving this language had been addressed in reported cases, and the franchisors involved had prevailed in them. Then, after observing that workers&rsquo; wages were not growing, despite increased economic growth and growing rates of employment, two economics professors published a paper, which was summarized in The New York Times, postulating that anti-poaching language in franchise agreements could be the cause of stagnant wages in franchise systems. &nbsp;Although anyone who carefully reads the study can see flaws in the assumptions and conclusions presented, politicians and class action plaintiffs&rsquo; lawyers saw opportunities for headlines and payouts, and incorporated the findings into class action claims, state attorney general investigations settlement demands and into proposed legislation.

Because franchisors had rarely, if ever, enforced the clauses, and did not want to incur six- to seven figure defense costs, virtually every franchisor has agreed with state AGs to delete anti-poaching language from their agreements. They have done it, not because the law does not support the enforceability of the language&mdash;recent intervention in anti-poaching cases by the U.S. Department of Justice indicates that the clauses may often be lawful in the franchising context&mdash;but because they don&rsquo;t want to incur the cost of dealing with it. They would rather deal with some unhappy franchisees than pay the costs of defending the claims.

The lesson: When drafting language in franchise agreements, especially when enforceability of a provision may be unclear, discuss the likely cost of enforcing the clause, and determine if a less problematic approach to the problem can be drafted.

1851: What is the most rewarding aspect of your work?

Zwisler: The most rewarding aspect of my work is helping clients find ways to resolve complex questions in a relatively simple and straightforward manner. In our international practice, we help our clients to find the most economical ways to achieve their objectives, bringing to bear our experience, legal knowledge and our network of excellent local franchise counsel throughout the world. Structuring and implementing an international program can be complicated. When we can provide strategic options that others had not considered to close a deal or to resolve a dispute, we have had a good day.

1851: What are your top concerns for the franchise industry in the next year?

Zwisler: Dealing with backlash from foreign governments and foreign franchisees and prospects over U.S. trade and economic and defense policies is a concern, especially for international franchisors. We are concerned that worries about what will happen next will cool the ardor for U.S. brands. We are also seeing significant regulatory threats to franchising in a growing number of countries, including in Australia, Egypt, the Netherlands and Saudi Arabia, to name a few countries. We will also be watching the study of franchising that is being undertaken by the E.U., to see if the E.U. proposes comprehensive E.U.-wide franchise regulation. In the U.S., we will be watching proposals to make post-term noncompete clauses unlawful or impractical at both the state and federal levels.

1851: What are you most optimistic about in the franchise industry in the next year?

Zwisler: So long as the U.S. economy continues to be strong, franchising will remain strong. &nbsp;We are optimistic that the FTC Franchise Rule will not undergo material changes and that the FTC will leave the Rule in place. Since the Rule became effective, only one state has adopted a franchise registration law and the Rule has brought general uniformity to franchise disclosure requirements. We also anticipate improved regulations explaining when joint employer liability will exist and what the consequences will be.

Carl Zwisler | Franchise Legal Player | 1851 Franchise

1851 Franchise

As part of its annual Franchise Legal Players issue, 1851 profiled the top franchise attorneys in the field to shine a spotlight on the work they do for the franchise industry.

Franchise Legal Players: Carl Zwisler, Principal at Gray Plant Mooty

franchise-legal-players-carl-zwisler-principal-at-gray-plant-mooty

Children's Lighthouse

Children’s Lighthouse Wraps Up Q1 With Two New Openings and Continued Industry Recognition

childrens-lighthouse-wraps-up-q1-with-two-new-openings-and-continued-industry-recognition

Happy Joe’s Franchising

Why Texas Is the Perfect State To Open a Happy Joe’s Franchise

why-texas-is-the-perfect-state-to-open-a-happy-joes-franchise

Seniors Helping Seniors®

Photo of two people, with white hair, sitting on couch, smiling at each other

Seniors Helping Seniors® In-Home Care Services Expands in Manassas and Fredericksburg, Virginia

seniors-helping-seniors-in-home-care-services-expands-in-manassas-and-fredericksburg-virginia

BooXkeeping

Tech-Driven Bookkeeping: How BooXkeeping Franchisees Are Embracing the Future

tech-driven-bookkeeping-how-booxkeeping-franchisees-are-embracing-the-future

Fitness Premier

Fitness Premier's State-of-the-Art Facilities and Multi-Discipline Approach Fuels Franchise Owner Success

fitness-premiers-state-of-the-art-facilities-and-multi-discipline-approach-fuels-franchise-owner-success

Buying a Franchise Masterclass

 Franchise Opportunities

Get Support Buying a Franchise

How to Buy a Franchise White Paper

How to Buy a Franchise

How to Sell Franchises

How to Grow a Franchise

Find a Franchise Supplier

1851 Franchise Opportunities

Franchisor News

Franchisor Power Rankings

FranCamp Mastermind Summit

Franchise Resources

What ALEC-Laffer's Report Means for Franchising

Website Awards

Power Rankings

About 1851

Advertise on 1851

Contact 1851 Editorial

Terms of Use

1851 Login

GROWTH CLUB LOGIN

facebook

instagram

twitter

linkedin

youtube

Layoffs Surge to Pandemic-Era Highs, Opening Doors for Franchise Growth

layoffs-surge-to-pandemic-era-highs-opening-doors-for-franchise-growth

FAT Brands Becomes First Restaurant Franchise To Accept Bitcoin for Royalty Payments

fat-brands-becomes-first-restaurant-franchise-to-accept-bitcoin-for-royalty-payments

Yum! Brands CEO David Gibbs To Retire in 2026 After 36 Years With the Company

yum-brands-ceo-david-gibbs-to-retire-in-2026-after-36-years-with-the-company

Hooters Bankruptcy - Chapter 11 - April 2025 - 1851 Franchise

Hooters Files for Bankruptcy, Sells Restaurants to Franchisee Group

hooters-bankruptcy-chapter-11-april-2025

Fly Dance Fitness Expands With First Franchise Location in Georgia

fly-dance-fitness-franchise-expansion

franchise supplier award design with Locate AI logo and 1851 Franchise badge

Franchise Real Estate Services | Locate AI — Emerging Leaders in Franchise Support

locate-ai-emerging-leaders-in-franchise-support

Emerging Leaders in Franchise Support: 1851 Supplier Highlights

Emerging Leaders in Franchise Support: List of Franchise Suppliers

emerging-leaders-in-franchise-support

Coffee and Analytics: Franchising and AI — Future-Proofing Your Business in an Uncertain Economy

franchising-and-ai-economic-uncertainty

Coffee & Analytics: The Secret to Attracting Multi-Unit Franchisees

coffee-analytics-the-secret-to-attracting-multi-unit-franchisees

Florida Franchisee Reflects on Success and Growth with Sylvan Learning

florida-franchisee-reflects-on-success-and-growth-with-sylvan-learning

Paris Baguette Ranks Among Top Franchises on Entrepreneur’s Franchise 500® for 2025 - 1851 Franchise

Paris Baguette Ranks Among Top Franchises on Entrepreneur’s Franchise 500® for 2025

paris-baguette-ranks-among-top-franchises-on-entrepreneurs-franchise-500-for-2025

Franchise Deep Dive: Studio Pilates Franchise Costs, Fees, Profit and Data

franchise-deep-dive-studio-pilates-franchise-costs-fees-profit-and-data

Military Veteran and Craft Beer Enthusiast to Bring Voodoo Brewing Co. to Toledo, Ohio

military-veteran-and-craft-beer-enthusiast-to-bring-voodoo-brewing-co-to-toledo-ohio

Franchise Legal Players: Carl Zwisler, Principal at Gray Plant Mooty

MORE STORIES LIKE THIS