1851

As the economy continues to reel from COVID-19, companies impacted by pandemic-related shutdown orders have been looking for ways to get insurers to pay business interruption claims.&nbsp;There are millions of claims by small businesses that want their insurers to cover their losses from COVID-19 lockdowns. The problem for many businesses is that they’re required to show physical loss or damages to make a claim for business interruption. Plus, even if policyholders could invoke business interruption or civil authority coverage to address mandatory shutdowns, many policies contain an exclusion for closures attributable to viruses or bacteria. Some also exclude civil actions, such as the government-mandated shutdown.&nbsp;Now, there are many state legislatures considering laws to force the industry to provide retroactive coverage to policyholders, regardless of the language of their insurance contract. In fact, at least <a href="https://www.huntonak.com/en/covid-19-tracker.html?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=will-business-owners-be-able-to-seek-covid-19-related-insurance-claims-2713935" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">1,000 cases are pending</a> in courts, according to one estimate.In August, Judge Stephen Bough of the Western District of Missouri <a href="https://www.insurancejournal.com/app/uploads/2020/08/studio-417-v-cincinnati-insurance.pdf?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=will-business-owners-be-able-to-seek-covid-19-related-insurance-claims-2713935" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">gave the go-ahead</a> to a handful of small businesses in Cincinnati to proceed with their case against property and casualty insurer Cincinnati Insurance Company over its refusal to pay business interruption insurance claims.The insurer had sought dismissal on grounds that its coverage is only for physical damage to a property, not an unseen virus outbreak. But the judge said the case should proceed to discovery because it's not clear the virus hasn't affected the businesses in a physical way.&nbsp;"Discovery will shed light on the merits of Plaintiffs' allegations, including the nature and extent of COVID-19 on their premises," he wrote. "COVID-19 allegedly attached to and deprived Plaintiffs of their property, making it 'unsafe and unusable, resulting in direct physical loss to the premises and property.'"The Cincinnati case was the first in which the judge refused to accept at face value insurers' assertion the virus doesn't qualify as physical damage to a property; in three previous cases since the pandemic hit, judges dismissed the suits.&nbsp;It is hard to say if other judges will follow Bough’s lead. <a href="http://www.pciaa.net/?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=will-business-owners-be-able-to-seek-covid-19-related-insurance-claims-2713935" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA)</a> says business interruption insurance was never intended to cover the impact of a pandemic because a pandemic is not something that can be underwritten against. Many commercial insurers worry that if they’re forced under proposed state laws to liquidate those reserves to pay policyholders for virus-related losses, insurers won’t be able to pay other legitimate claims and it could bankrupt the insurance industry.John Houghtaling, an attorney representing several businesses in COVID-related lawsuits and the head of <a href="https://werbig.org/?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=will-business-owners-be-able-to-seek-covid-19-related-insurance-claims-2713935" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">Business Interruption Group</a>, a coalition of businesses seeking relief, says insurers should pay claims if the policies don’t have these explicit exclusions.&nbsp;"We are banding together to launch big legal action in every state against insurers who deny ... coverage," <a href="https://www.cfodive.com/news/restaurants-insurers-pay-business-interruption-claims/577243/?utm_source=1851franchise.com&utm_medium=article&utm_campaign=will-business-owners-be-able-to-seek-covid-19-related-insurance-claims-2713935" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">Houghtaling told CFODive</a>.&nbsp;Houghtaling’s coalition is also advocating for a legislative solution for insurers as well. His group wants the federal government to create a fund with which it would reimburse insurers who pay the claims even if they have an exclusion.&nbsp;The group sees that as a more appropriate solution than some others that have been floated, including one approach that would require insurers to pay regardless of whether the policy has an exclusion or not.

Will Business Owners Be Able to Seek COVID-19-Related Insurance Claims?

1851 Franchise

Restaurants and other businesses hit by pandemic shutdowns are starting to move forward on legal efforts to get insurers to pay on business interruption policies.

will-business-owners-be-able-to-seek-covid-19-related-insurance-claims

TruBlue Home Service Ally

TruBlue Featured in USA Today as Key Player in Helping Seniors Age Safely at Home

trublue-featured-in-usa-today-as-key-player-in-helping-seniors-age-safely-at-home

Right at Home

Right at Home Marks 30 Years With Continued Franchise Growth

Right at Home Marks 30 Years With Continued Franchise Growth, Tech Advancements, and Strong System Engagement in First Half of 2025

right-at-home-franchise-growth-2025

KidStrong Franchising, LLC

Unlocking Superpowers: How KidStrong Is Building the Next Generation of Confident Kids — and Thriving Franchise Owners

kidstrong-franchise-confident-kids

Image of a kid growing up, developing with kidstrong, high fiving and smiling. 

How KidStrong has Become the Franchise Disrupting Child Development by Partnering with Purpose-Driven Franchise Owners 

kidstrong-franchise-opportunity-child-development

Picture of kids for franchise business Kidstrong which focuses on child development and fitness

KidStrong Is Pediatrician-Recommended for Raising Confident, Capable Kids and Families Can't Get Enough

kidstrong-child-development-program

Buying a Franchise Masterclass

 Franchise Opportunities

Get Support Buying a Franchise

How to Buy a Franchise White Paper

How to Buy a Franchise

How to Sell Franchises

How to Grow a Franchise

Find a Franchise Supplier

1851 Franchise Opportunities

Franchisor News

Franchisor Power Rankings

FranCamp Mastermind Summit

Franchise Development Website Builder

Franchise Resources

What ALEC-Laffer's Report Means for Franchising

Website Awards

Power Rankings

About 1851

Advertise on 1851

Contact 1851 Editorial

Terms of Use

1851 Login

GROWTH CLUB LOGIN

facebook

instagram

twitter

linkedin

youtube

Image of Donald Trump pointing with red stripes in the background

August 1 Tariff Deadline Is Said to Have ‘No Extensions’: What This Could Mean for Franchises

august-1-tariff-deadline-franchise-impact

What June’s Jobs Report Means for the Franchise Industry

what-junes-jobs-report-means-for-the-franchise-industry

Drone Delivery Takes Flight in QSR: The Future of Franchise Operations?

drone-delivery-takes-flight-in-qsr-the-future-of-franchise-operations

Chick-fil-A Tops Customer Satisfaction Rankings for 11th Year as Challenger Brands Gain Ground

chick-fil-a-tops-customer-satisfaction-rankings-for-11th-year-as-challenger-brands-gain-ground

Technomic Releases Annual Ranking of the Top 15 Fast-Food Chains in the U.S.

technomic-releases-annual-ranking-of-the-top-15-fast-food-chains-in-the-us

Hooters Leans Into Franchising With Closure of 30 Company-Owned Stores - Agg - 1851 Franchise

Hooters Leans Into Franchising With Closure of 30 Company-Owned Stores

hooters-franchise-model-company-owned-closures

Rising Jobless Claims Could Signal Challenges — and Opportunities — for Franchising

rising-jobless-claims-affect-franchising

The Ultimate Guide to Selling Franchises: How To Create a Strong Incentive

how-to-build-strong-incentives-to-attract-prospective-franchisees

Franchisee spotlight graphic with photo of Ricki Oberoi and Layne's Chicken Fingers logo

Multi-Unit Wendy’s Operator Signs 12-Unit Deal With Layne’s Chicken Fingers

ricki-oberoi-laynes-chicken-fingers-growth

How Vishal Juneja Turned a Family Tradition Into a Paris Baguette Franchise

How Vishal Juneja Turned a Family Tradition Into a Paris Baguette Franchise Built on Heart and Community

paris-baguette-franchise-rockaway-new-jersey-vishal-junjea

Franchisee spotlight graphic with photos of Danielle Rosemond & Usman Khan & TruBlue logo

Family Members of Local Physicians Bring TruBlue Franchise to North Central Nassau, Long Island: A Health Care-Inspired Approach to Aging in Place

family-brings-trublue-franchise-to-north-central-nassau

Top 25 Franchise Marketing Leaders: Kelsey McManemin — Vice President of Marketing, HTeaO

top-25-franchise-marketing-leaders-kelsey-mcmanemin-vice-president-of-marketing-hteao

Will Business Owners Be Able to Seek COVID-19-Related Insurance Claims?

MORE STORIES LIKE THIS