How Regulation Impacts Franchising: The Pros and Cons

Franchising offers substantial opportunities for growth and wealth creation. Regulation in franchising serves as a critical safeguard for both franchisors and franchisees. Without it, the immense opportunities within the franchise industry could lead to hasty decisions and potential exploitation. However, very strict regulations can hinder growth and progress. 

1851 Franchise spoke with Tom O’Connell, a franchise attorney with the business law firm Buchalter, about how regulation impacts franchising. 

Regulation Provides a Safeguard

“Franchising has exponentially expanded over the last century,” said O’Connell. “It has evolved into one of the most powerful and stable opportunities for a business to grow as well as for individuals to create generational wealth.”

However, with this growth potential comes the necessity for regulation to ensure fair play and protect all parties involved. Regulatory framework within the franchising industry helps prevent the kind of unchecked expansion that might harm smaller franchisees or lead to unethical practices.

“Well thought out franchise regulation is one of the most important guardrails that protects both franchisors and franchisees,” said O’Connell.

Effective regulatory frameworks serve as crucial safeguards against potential abuses and exploitation. These regulations help prevent unchecked expansion, which could harm smaller franchisees or encourage unethical practices. By setting clear standards and expectations, regulations ensure a level playing field and protect the integrity of the franchise system.

The Challenges of Strict Regulation

While regulation is essential, overly stringent rules can stifle innovation and impede growth. 

“A substantial portion of my practice relates to compliance with California’s unique regulatory frameworks. They are complex, restrictive and can be intimidating to new and old franchisors alike,” said O’Connell. “Indeed, franchisors and franchisees have chosen to leave the state or not enter the state in the first place because of them. As a result, California — particularly over the last decade — has become the example of how the appearance of an anti-franchising environment can smother growth and innovation in what should be one of the most ripe economies in the world.”

While there can be significant drawbacks to overly restrictive rules, O’Connell believes that doing away with regulation altogether is not the answer.

“Our best franchisors, franchise organizations and even franchisor-side attorneys are the strongest advocates for responsible franchising regulations,” he said. “In much the same way that brand standards protect and enhance a franchise, clear and logical franchise regulations are absolutely necessary to protect and enhance industry at large and allow for positive growth and innovation.” 

Looking ahead, technological advancements and shifting consumer preferences will undoubtedly influence future regulatory changes. 

O’Connell predicts that “technology will continue to increase employee mobility,” necessitating new franchise registration laws to accommodate emerging economic markets. Additionally, O’Connell believes the rise of gig work and AI will intersect with employment regulations, further shaping the franchise landscape.

While regulation is a necessary safeguard that ensures fair play and protects all stakeholders, excessive regulation can hinder growth and innovation. Striking the right balance is key to fostering a thriving franchise industry that benefits both franchisors and franchisees.

Every great franchisee had help buying a franchise. Want to learn more about how 1851 helps franchisees find the right franchise opportunity? Visit www.1851growthclub.com and start your journey.